The 2012 Hot Docs Forum Full Report
DocMovies examine all 26 feature doc projects pitched at the annual event, along with detailed judges responses and analysis. This report was written by director Eli Brown, owner of of Postbrooklyn, a production and post-production studio based in Brooklyn, NY. Made possible thanks to filmmaker and Hot Docs Pitch Fourm particpant Hilla Medalia

1. The Audacity of Louis Ortiz. The film details the unusual life of a man who happens to look very much like Barack Obama. There is a somewhat lukewarm reception from panel. Overseas Commissioning Editors (CEs) are not that interested; American CEs are more interested, but the project can’t be legitimately called a home run for this team. ITVS mentions that they should apply for their Open Call – June 29th; mark your calendars!
2. Sand Wars. Fairly sweeping epic documentary about the fast depleting natural resource of silica sand. Trailer was very traditional doc style (pulse pounding music, talking heads, and the like). It’s an untold story, global consequences – fits well at ZDF (who was working with the production team, and was therefore seated at the table for the pitch). ZDF has a slot on their channel for projects like this. This is the second consecutive pitch that received some criticism from the CEs on the panel for not having a clearly defined story arc they could discern from the trailer and pitch. During the discussion between the filmmakers and the panel, it appears that the documentary might have a split focus (according to the panel). The panel seems to like the mafia-crime controlling the depletion of a natural resource angle, not the environmental disaster angle as much. So, maybe crime does pay. Also, they didn't show any characters in the trailer, so PBS had questions regarding that, as to which strand to place it in if they were to get on board with the film.
3. Zanta. An intimate story about a Tibetan street peddler that transitions into a family story of single mother caught between two worlds (Tibet and China) that are a bit unknown to many western audiences. The CEs respond: POV is interested in this story but want to see more of the story arc. (Wow! 3 for 3. Story arc is the single hardest thing to put together in a short 7 minute pitch, not surprisingly). Tribeca was curious as to what the role of the filmmaker would be. The trailer impressed the panel, overall. Seemed like it got the most interest of the first 3 pitches.
4. Filmmaker couldn't make it, so Britdoc Foundation supporter framed it. About a Swaziland woman's struggle.They need to get an international co-pro in order to move the project forward.
Second Round! New moderators, more people in the audience, a few different panelists. CNN is one of the new CEs at the table -- maybe reflecting their "all-acquisition" strategy for their documentary division that was announced relatively recently.
5. Holy Ghetto. Producer Chico Colvard does a pretty long preface about why he got involved. Then DER talks as "fiscal sponsor." But I feel like the clock is almost done and I haven't seen the trailer or even heard from the filmmaker. The film is about human trafficking in Israel. Their presentation went over by 3 minutes, but no one wrestled them to the floor. The trailer has some strong characters that the panel seems to respond to well. DR questions the title, as in what the "holy" part of the title means. (Editorializing: I agree with DR and the title doesn't quite work since they're not dealing with a religious construct, but rather human trafficking). Chico chimes in that he also wants to change the title, so problem solved! Again, story arc is a bit confusing from the trailer. Panel seems to encourage the filmmaker to follow the women's stories rather than a "current affairs" style of documentary, so there are some difficult choices for the filmmaker to make in bringing the project to fruition.







